
When GM announced the Chevy Volt should be rated at 230 MPG in city driving, they also divulged another efficiency rating.
Pure electric cars are generally rated in terms of kwh per 100 miles to show how efficient the vehilce is at using electrical energy. Since the Volt will drive the first 40 miles without gas it is appropriate to apply that metric to those miles.
Per GM’s press release, “applying EPA’s methodology, GM expects the Volt to consume as little as 25 kilowatt hours per 100 miles in city driving.” GM noted that this methodology is new and still under development in draft form.
Since we know the Volt will be able to use a maximum of 8 kwh of energy storage, then it could be concluded the Volt’s all electric range (AER) should come out only to 32 miles in city driving [100 mi/25 kwh x 8 kwh = 32 mi]. This is lower than the omnipresent 40 miles GM has stated since the beginning.
I sought clarification from Volt executive Frank Weber.
“The Volt is achieving 40 miles in the city and highway cycle, ” he said. “Nothing has changed.”
He noted however that in the new testing methodology “EPA is assuming a daily charge and is applying some real world factors that will degrade the EV range.”
“EPA has considered varying temperature and drive style conditions in their methodology,” explains Weber defining what he means by real world factors, and distinguishing how the new test differs from the old one.
“The cycle tests are run at a single temp and would not reflect range variation due to accessory loads,” said Weber referring to the older methodology from which the 40 mile designation was originally estimated.
I contacted Andrew Simpson, who is a Senior Research Fellow in plug-in vehicle technology at Curtin University, Australia, and previously worked at Tesla Motors and completed the EPA range certification testing of the Tesla Roadster. He said the older method is called “the SAE Recommended Practice J1634 “Electric Vehicle Energy Consumption and Range Test Procedure”. However, he notes “the standard is a bit outdated and SAE have formed a committee to revise it.” It is this committee that has written the draft.
“The revised 1634 procedure is an abbreviated version of the previous and consists of a battery capacity/characterization test followed by an finite number of drive cycles to measure energy consumption and estimate range,” said Vineet Mehta also of Tesla Motors.
The original J1634 procedure was written in 1993 and technically discontinued in 2003. The revised SAE J1634 draft is expected to be completed by December 2009.
So will the Volt still get 40 miles under real world standard conditions in the city? And what will the number be on the highway? These facts as well as the Volt’s MPG in generator node remain undisclosed.
It is important realize that EV ranges will vary considerably from what the manufacturer claims just as MPG does, and depend considerably on driving aggressiveness and use of accessory loads.
The sticker shown above was for the original EV-1 showing how the car got 30 kwh/100 miles in the city and a 20% more efficient 25 kwh/100 miles on the highway.





