Yesterday we finally heard some information directly from the EPA about their plans to create and finalize new fuel efficiency labels that could be applied to advanced technology vehicles like the Volt.
Mainly there is a distinction between two major design change options, a system rating cars from A+ through D- based on how much emissions they produced or a more conventional label without the letter grade. Both labels display a vehicle’s efficiency in terms of mile per gallon equivalents (MPGe) whenever electricity is used or miles per gallon (MPG) when gas is used. This same method is used in the letter grade labels in which case the pure EV gets an A+, and the PHEV gets an A. Conventional gas cars get a C or D.
MPGe is given by the formula: MPGe = (miles driven) / [(total energy of all fuels consumed)/(energy of one gallon of gasoline)]). For example, an electric car with an efficiency of 200 watt-hours per mile (like the Volt) would be rated at 168.5 MPGe.
There is some controversy though about whether MPGe should be used at all.
Mike Duoba is a scientist at the Argonne National Lab who is the leader of a team that created the J1711 methodology for determining fuell efficiency of PHEVs. Duoba isn’t particularly happy about using MPGe for electric mode operation. “I am worried that EPA is responding to the focus group conclusion that MPG is familiar so it must be used for EV mode,” he said. “Crazy talk.”
Duoba confirmed that the J1711 is still in effect. “EPA is using J1711, its just that J1711 does not combine them magically into a single MPG value,” he said.
“For blended mode operation, things will get very complicated,” he added. “The EPA proposal is just plain wrong.”
At this point the EPA proposal is just that, a proposal; it isn’t finalized. The agency is looking for the public’s opinion and comments over the next 60 days before a final ruling is made.
The EPA has proposed two separate and different labels for blended PHEVs that use gas whenever power demands it and extended range electric cars (EREVs) like the Volt that only use electricity for the first certain number of miles driven (40 in the case of the Volt). The labels shows MPGe for the whole pure electric range in both vehicle types, and both show MPG when running only on gas after the battery is depleted. Having separate labels could make the EREV look better to the casual observer when compared side by side, and favor the Volt. However, the decision to have separate labels for PHEVs and EREVs isnt finalized.
When asked specifically about it Cathy Milbourn of the EPA said “no final decision has been made on any aspect of the labels.”
“Its out for public comment,” she added. “We want to hear from the public about what they would like to see on the label.”
An so they shall. Take the polls below, and I’ll send the results to the EPA.
You may also send your individual comments to newlabels@epa.gov.



















