Electric cars not only offer instantaneous torque but continue to provide linear acceleration throughout the driving velocity range. Torque and acceleration are greatest at the low-end and then flatten out as high speeds are reached.
One reporter’s observation of a 67% calibration Volt prototype on the highway brought into question highway performance. As some here may know, I recently had the opportunity to experience a near-final Volt going from 55 to 80 mph ont the highway and although linear felt performance was quite acceptable.
Combustion engine cars operate differently. At higher speeds, if the driver floors the accelerator pedal, the automatic transmission will shift down a gear, engine speed and torque will increase, and the car will accelerate. Among the uninitiated, the lack of this type of responsiveness could disturb some would-be electric car buyers.
As far as I can tell, or know, the Volt does not simulate this experience.
However, according to a test drive from Edmund’s Inside Line, the LEAF does. Apparently Nissan believes it was necessary to reproduce the passing gear experience in its electric car for greatest customer acceptance.
Edmund’s reports the following statement as attributed to Mark Perry who Nissan North American product planning and advanced technology director:
Engineers programmed the electronics to add a bit of power at the very end of the accelerator pedal’s travel, and when you floor the Leaf you do feel a little extra surge – not quite like having a passing gear, but enough to let you know the powertrain is responding to the signal your right foot is sending.
Edmund’s apparently did not get it quite right though with this description per a direct communication between Perry and GM-Volt.
“The (LEAF) electric motor still has sufficient torque to have good passing speed from 55 to 70,” Perry told GM-Volt. There are “no gears or “step down.” With respect to O’Dells comments, “he mixed two pieces of info but intention is correct,” said Perry.
Nonetheless, some other interesting comparisons between the LEAF and Volt were delineated in this review.
The LEAF, as does the Volt, has both a normal braking mode and an eco braking mode which gives the driver a little regenerative drag, allowing the car to be slowed without the brakes. The LEAF, however, has only a normal and Eco power mode (slower) which determines overall driving power. The Volt has a normal and a sports power modes, with the sports mode adding about 20 kw of power. The fact that the Volt has more power and acceleration speed may be part of the reason why GM engineers didn’t think a passing gear simulation was necessary on the Volt. The LEAF motor’s peak power is 80 kw, whereas the Volt’s is 110 kw. The LEAF has a CD of 0.29, the Volt’s is 0.28, the LEAF weighs about 3500 pounds and the Volt 3900 lb due to the presence of the gas engine.
A surprising point of the LEAF review is that Nissan allowed the journalist to take the test car up and down public roads in San Diego, even up to 82 mph. GM has said it is legally “not allowed” to let anyone but GM employees drive Volt prototypes on public roads, and thus all media drives have taken place on pylon-lined parking-lot based test courses. That is everyone expect Jay Leno, who for some reason did get to take the Volt on public roads.
The presence or absence of a passing gear simulation on an electric car is an interesting issue. How important do you think it is?
Source (Edmunds)






